The Court also ruled that Congress lacked power to ban slavery in the U. Finally, the Court declared that the rights of slaveowners were constitutionally protected by the Fifth Amendment because slaves were categorized as property. The controversy began in , when Dr. John Emerson, a surgeon with the U. Army, purchased Dred Scott, a slave, and eventually moved Scott to a base in the Wisconsin Territory.
Slavery was banned in the territory pursuant to the Missouri Compromise. Scott lived there for the next four years, hiring himself out for work during the long stretches when Emerson was away. In , Scott, his new wife, and their young children moved to Louisiana and then to St.
Louis with Emerson. Emerson died in , leaving the Scott family to his wife, Eliza Irene Sanford. In , after laboring and saving for years, the Scotts sought to buy their freedom from Sanford, but she refused.
Dred Scott then sued Sanford in a state court, arguing that he was legally free because he and his family had lived in a territory where slavery was banned. In , the state court finally declared Scott free.
However, Scott's wages had been withheld pending the resolution of his case, and during that time Mrs. Emerson remarried and left her brother, John Sanford, to deal with her affairs. Sanford, unwilling to pay the back wages owed to Scott, appealed the decision to the Missouri Supreme Court. Resource Bank Contents. Dred Scott first went to trial to sue for his freedom in Ten years later, after a decade of appeals and court reversals, his case was finally brought before the United States Supreme Court.
In what is perhaps the most infamous case in its history, the court decided that all people of African ancestry -- slaves as well as those who were free -- could never become citizens of the United States and therefore could not sue in federal court.
The court also ruled that the federal government did not have the power to prohibit slavery in its territories. Scott, needless to say, remained a slave. Born around , Scott migrated westward with his master, Peter Blow.
They travelled from Scott's home state of Virginia to Alabama and then, in , to St. Louis, Missouri. Two years later Peter Blow died; Scott was subsequently bought by army surgeon Dr.
John Emerson, who later took Scott to the free state of Illinois. In the spring of , after a stay of two and a half years, Emerson moved to a fort in the Wisconsin Territory, taking Scott along.
While there, Scott met and married Harriet Robinson, a slave owned by a local justice of the peace. Ownership of Harriet was transferred to Emerson. Scott's extended stay in Illinois, a free state, gave him the legal standing to make a claim for freedom, as did his extended stay in Wisconsin, where slavery was also prohibited.
But Scott never made the claim while living in the free lands -- perhaps because he was unaware of his rights at the time, or perhaps because he was content with his master.
Instead, she prefers describing those historical events to her students. Both Steilen and Shapiro came to these conclusions without pressure from students; they said they had not heard concerns or complaints. Among the changes the movement has spurred are stronger efforts to teach the history and theory of racial injustice, in schools at every level. Sometimes the two converge in advocating the editing out of racist content that is deemed too upsetting to be worth the pedagogical benefits.
When it comes to law school, the truth is that to learn constitutional law is to become well versed in techniques of legal interpretation that have enabled deeply unjust results. In the nineteen-forties, they might have written a legal brief condoning the internment of Japanese-Americans. And in recent years, law graduates justified the so-called Muslim ban and the separation of families at the border.
Next year, Bowie will publish a new constitutional-law casebook; his edited text of Dred Scott v. The fact that it is so disturbing when it is so visible is why purveyors of constitutional law might have the impulse to obscure it. New Yorker Favorites The day the dinosaurs died. What if you could do it all over? A suspense novelist leaves a trail of deceptions. The art of dying.
0コメント